France fines Google $381M for Gmail ads and cookie tracking without consent
What Happened: France Slaps Google with Massive Privacy Fine
France Strikes Google – Fine $381 Million for Gmail Ads and Cookie Consent Violations – In a major privacy enforcement move, France’s data protection authority CNIL has fined Google €325 million ($381 million) for violating user privacy laws. The penalty stems from two key issues: ads placed inside Gmail inboxes and cookie tracking during account creation, both done without proper user consent.
According to CNIL, Google displayed promotional emails directly in users’ Gmail inboxes, especially in the “Promotions” and “Social” tabs without asking for permission. Additionally, when users created a new Google account, they were automatically opted into ad tracking cookies, with no clear way to refuse or understand the implications.
These practices violated the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the ePrivacy Directive, which require companies to obtain freely given, informed, and specific consent before collecting personal data or showing targeted ads.
Gmail Ads and Cookie Consent: What Went Wrong
CNIL’s investigation revealed that Google’s interface encouraged users to accept personalized ads while making it harder to opt out. This design, often called a “dark pattern”, nudged users toward choices that benefited the company’s advertising model.
The Gmail ads were treated as direct marketing messages, which under French law require prior consent. CNIL found that 53 million Gmail users in France were affected by these ad placements. Meanwhile, over 74 million accounts were impacted by the cookie consent violations during account setup.
In short, Google failed to:
- Clearly inform users about ad tracking.
- Offer a simple opt-out option.
- Obtain valid consent before placing cookies or ads.
These actions were deemed coercive and misleading, undermining user autonomy and violating core principles of digital privacy.
CNIL’s Verdict and Google’s Response
CNIL issued two separate fines:
- €200 million against Google LLC (U.S. entity)
- €125 million against Google Ireland Ltd (EU entity)
The regulator also gave Google six months to fix the issues. If the company fails to comply, it will face daily penalties of €100,000 until changes are made.
A Google spokesperson responded by saying the company is reviewing the decision and emphasized that users have always had control over their ad settings. Google also pointed out that it has made recent updates, including:
- Easier ways to decline personalized ads during account creation.
- Changes to how ads appear in Gmail.
However, CNIL concluded that these updates were not enough to fix past violations, and the fine reflects the scale and seriousness of the breach.
Why This Matters: A Wake-Up Call for Big Tech
This fine is part of a broader trend of global scrutiny on tech giants over privacy practices. In recent years, CNIL has fined Google multiple times:
- €100 million in 2020 for cookie violations.
- €150 million in 2022 for lack of opt-out options.
- €250 million in 2024 for training its AI chatbot on publisher content without consent.
The latest €325 million fine is the largest privacy penalty ever imposed by France, and it sends a clear message: user consent is not optional.
For users, this case highlights the importance of:
- Reading privacy settings carefully.
- Understanding how data is used.
- Demanding transparency from digital platforms.
For companies, it’s a reminder that GDPR enforcement is real, and violations can lead to serious financial and reputational damage.
The fine also shows that Europe is leading the way in digital rights enforcement. With GDPR in place, regulators have the power to hold even the biggest tech giants accountable. Other countries, including India, are watching closely and may follow with similar laws and actions.
Final Thoughts: Google’s $381 million fine in France is more than just a headline, it’s a turning point in the fight for digital rights. As regulators tighten their grip, tech companies must rethink how they handle user data. Consent must be clear, honest, and optional not buried in fine print or forced through design.
Also read – Google Pixel 10: AI-Powered Flagship with Tensor G5 & 64MP Camera Launching August 20
Stay informed with the latest news and updates – only on Rapido Updates.